The Lawsuit

Estate of John A. Mead v. Middlebury College

In September 2021, Middlebury College removed the Mead name from the chapel. In March 2023 the Mead estate filed suit, alleging breach of covenant. The case is now before the Vermont Supreme Court.

A Message

Message from Governor Jim Douglas

Former Vermont Governor Jim Douglas, administrator of the Mead estate, has spoken to why this case matters - and why the promises behind the chapel deserve to be honored. His full statement will appear here.

Read his statement on the original site →

Timeline

Case History

1916

The Gift

Gov. John A. Mead donates the chapel to Middlebury College.

2021

The Name Removed

Middlebury strips the Mead name from the building in September.

2023

Suit Filed

The Mead estate sues, alleging breach of covenant. A judge lets it proceed.

2025

Appeal to the High Court

After a Superior Court ruling, the estate appeals to the Vermont Supreme Court and is now waiting on a verdit.

Parties & Counsel

Plaintiff / AppellantEstate of John A. Mead (Jim Douglas, Administrator)
Defendant / AppelleeMiddlebury College
Plaintiff's CounselL. Brooke Dingledine, Valsangiacomo & Pelkey, P.C.
Defendant's CounselJustin Barnard, Dinse P.C.

View case documents →Source material & evidenceContact us